Where are they now? Sheila's real-life Lighthouse

Lighthouses are a popular Cat’s Meow item with collectors usually buying more than one to include in their home décor. But what if buying a Cat’s Meow replica just isn’t enough?

Sheila's lighthouse from 2011 to today. Photos: Fairport Harbor Lighthouse Facebook


Long time Cat’s Meower, Sheila Consaul boasts about owning a “ton of Cat’s Meows” including her prized collection of Skaneateles, NY where she grew up.


But when it came to lighthouses, she had to buy the real thing! That’s right, you read correctly…a real, live, sitting-on-the-water lighthouse! And…since she now owned a lighthouse, the next natural thing to do was create a Cat’s Meow keepsake. That’s how we learned of Sheila’s story.


“I have done historic preservation in the past,” related Sheila, “and I was looking for an unusual property for a summer home when I heard the government was auctioning off lighthouses.” So in 2009, she bid on the Fairport Harbor West Breakwater Lighthouse. Four bids later in 2011 Sheila finally owned a real lighthouse perched at the end of a break wall on Lake Erie.


Cat’s Meow & Fundraising:

As she was fundraising for the intense renovation process, Sheila created a Kickstarter campaign. Each pledge level on her Kickstarter included an appropriate reward.


As Sheila put together her pledge levels and rewards, she thought of Cat’s Meow and her own collection.



Sheila said that she loved Cat’s Meow's work and that “being an Ohio-based company, it totally made perfect sense” to offer a wooden replica of her lighthouse as one of the rewards. 


Of course, we at Cat’s Meow were so pleased to be a part of Sheila’s big project!


Since then…

“Since 2011, I’ve been renovating it, mostly cosmetic things.” Sheila adds, “The lighthouse is on the National Register Of Historic Places, so there are renovation standards I am required to adhere to.”


The inside of the lighthouse just needed a fresh layer of paint and floor refinishing. Sheila continues, “There’s no sewer, water, or electricity…back when it was occupied from 1925-1948, the keeper would have used a coal furnace, steam generator for electricity, and lake water.”



There are still renovations taking place, but the lighthouse is liveable minus the running water. Sheila has a modern kitchen, two bedrooms, and a bunkroom. All of her furnishings have been delivered by boat! 


When something is too heavy or awkward to carry -- such as furniture, cabinets, appliances, granite countertop, water treatment equipment, and tile -- it must be brought out by boat or specialized barge. The boat deliveries necessitate good weather, a great deal of coordination, and significant manpower.


Are you curious about what a liveable lighthouse looks like?   


Sheila provides free private tours throughout the summer by appointment and an annual Birthday Open House in June for the community to see the progress of the renovations. Her Birthday Open House draws over 600 people each year.


Fairport Harbor Lighthouse birthday party 2019. Photos: Fairport Harbor Lighthouse Facebook


We love being part of fundraisers and have supported many over the years. Our unique handmade replicas can help your next fundraiser. Want to learn more or brainstorm with us?  





Head on over to Instagram or Facebook to join in on our neighborhood conversations.



We handcraft all of our keepsakes in Ohio from ¾” thick wood with detailed front designs and written descriptions on the back. They can be set neatly on a shelf, desk, or narrow ledge such as wainscoting, window, or door trim.

Group them with other Cat’s Meows to create your own little Village!

Look for Casper, our black cat mascot, sitting or reclining within the design. He's the sign of an authentic Cat's Meow souvenir replica.



If you are new here, I am Faline Jones, creator and founder

Make sure you join our email list to get notified when a new blog is released.

When you join our list you also get exclusive discounts and updates on collections before anyone else! It’s definitely a fun place to be.

Sign up for our Mewsletter and move into the best neighborhood in our Village. You'll get your paws on monthly purrivileges including "insider" news and savings.


Check your inbox for a Welcome email with a SAVINGS code. Go dumpster diving if you don't find it.


We respect your email privacy



OMG! I'm formerly from Cleveland, Ohio (Fairport Harbor is maybe 30 minutes or a little more from Cleveland) and I have a dear friend that lives in Fairport Harbor. That is the COOLEST! I have watched shows on HGTV that feature unusual homes, and once I saw someone who lived in the taller kind of lighthouse (the thin ones), this one is sooooo cool! Would love to see the interior!
Nice to hear from a fellow Ohioan! The coolest thing is, you can visit and get a tour of this lighthouse by Sheila! All you need to do it follow her Facebook page and get on her website to find out when she is open for tours. She has mentioned to me that she offers them all summer long.

Add new comment

Comment Policy

Please join the conversation! We like long and thoughtful communication. Once you submit a comment, it will be reviewed by our staff before it is approved.